diff --git a/HACKATHON_REVIEW.md b/HACKATHON_REVIEW.md deleted file mode 100644 index 0539b50..0000000 --- a/HACKATHON_REVIEW.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,56 +0,0 @@ -# Hackathon Review: noentropy - -## Overall Assessment - -**Score: 8.5/10** - -`noentropy` is a highly effective and impressive hackathon project. Its core concept of using a Large Language Model (LLM) to automate the tedious task of file organization is both innovative and genuinely useful. The project is well-scoped for a hackathon, demonstrating a complete and functional loop from analyzing files to executing a plan. - -### Strengths - -* **High "Wow" Factor:** Demonstrates a practical and intelligent use of AI that solves a common problem. It's the kind of project that gets people excited. -* **Practical Usefulness:** This isn't just a technical demo; it's a tool that people would actually want to use to manage their cluttered "Downloads" folders. -* **Solid Technical Foundation:** The choice of Rust with `tokio` for asynchronous API calls is a good one, showing technical competence. The interaction with the Gemini API is direct and effective. -* **Complete End-to-End Loop:** The program successfully scans files, communicates with an external API, parses the response, and acts on it. - -## Suggested Improvements for a Winning Edge - -This project is already strong, but the following improvements could elevate it from a great project to a potential winner. - -### High-Impact Improvements - -1. **Configuration File for Categories:** - * **Problem:** The file categories (`Images`, `Documents`, etc.) are currently hardcoded in the prompt. This is inflexible. - * **Solution:** Create a `config.toml` file where users can define their own categories and maybe even provide rules (e.g., "all `.jpg` files go to `Photos`"). This would make the tool dramatically more powerful and personalizable. - -2. **Dry-Run Mode:** - * **Problem:** Users, especially first-time users, will be hesitant to run a tool that automatically moves their files without knowing what it's going to do. - * **Solution:** Add a `--dry-run` command-line flag. In this mode, the tool should print out the proposed file movements without actually touching any files. For example: `[DRY RUN] Would move 'report.pdf' to 'Documents/'`. - -3. **Interactive Mode:** - * **Problem:** The current process is fully automated. What if the AI makes a mistake? - * **Solution:** Add an `--interactive` flag. After getting the plan from Gemini, the tool could present the plan to the user and ask for confirmation for each move or for categories of moves. `Move 5 files to 'Images'? [Y/n]`. - -### Technical & Robustness Improvements - -4. **Correct the Model Name:** - * In `src/gemini.rs`, the model `gemini-3-flash-preview` is likely a typo. It should probably be `gemini-1.5-flash-preview` or another valid, available model. - -5. **Robust API Response Parsing:** - * **Problem:** The code manually traverses the JSON response from Gemini. If the API response structure changes even slightly, the program will crash. - * **Solution:** Define Rust structs that mirror the *entire* Gemini API response and use `serde` to deserialize into them. This is far more resilient to API changes. - -6. **Eliminate `.expect()`:** - * **Problem:** The code uses `.expect()` in several places (e.g., for environment variables and creating directories). This can cause the program to panic unexpectedly. - * **Solution:** Replace `.expect()` calls with proper `Result` handling and provide more user-friendly error messages. For example, if the `DOWNLOAD_FOLDER` isn't set, print a clear message telling the user how to set it. - -7. **More Context for the LLM:** - * **Problem:** Sending only filenames might not be enough for accurate categorization. Is `resume.pdf` a document or something else? - * **Solution:** To improve accuracy, consider sending more metadata to Gemini. The prompt could include file size, creation date, or even the first few lines of text for file types like `.txt` or `.md`. (This would require more complex file handling but would make the AI's job easier). - -### Feature Expansion - -8. **Recursive Folder Processing:** - * Add a `--recursive` or `-r` flag to allow the tool to organize files in subdirectories as well, not just the top-level directory. - -By implementing a few of these suggestions, particularly the high-impact ones, `noentropy` could be a truly standout project. Great work! diff --git a/README.md b/README.md index 09bc738..069a530 100644 --- a/README.md +++ b/README.md @@ -439,22 +439,61 @@ cargo check ## Project Structure +NoEntropy follows a clean modular architecture for better maintainability and testability: + ``` noentropy/ +├── .github/ +│ └── workflows/ +│ └── rust.yml # CI/CD workflow ├── src/ -│ ├── main.rs # Entry point and CLI handling -│ ├── lib.rs # Library exports -│ ├── config.rs # Configuration management -│ ├── gemini.rs # Gemini API client -│ ├── gemini_errors.rs # Error handling -│ ├── cache.rs # Caching system -│ ├── files.rs # File operations -│ └── undo.rs # Undo functionality -├── Cargo.toml # Dependencies -├── config.example.toml # Configuration template -└── README.md # This file +│ ├── cli/ +│ │ ├── mod.rs # CLI module exports +│ │ ├── args.rs # Command-line argument definitions +│ │ └── orchestrator.rs # Organization & undo orchestration +│ ├── files/ +│ │ ├── mod.rs # File module exports +│ │ ├── batch.rs # File batch processing +│ │ ├── detector.rs # File type detection +│ │ ├── mover.rs # File moving operations +│ │ └── undo.rs # Undo file operations +│ ├── gemini/ +│ │ ├── mod.rs # Gemini API module exports +│ │ ├── client.rs # Gemini API client +│ │ ├── errors.rs # Gemini error handling +│ │ ├── prompt.rs # AI prompt construction +│ │ └── types.rs # Gemini API types +│ ├── models/ +│ │ ├── mod.rs # Data models exports +│ │ ├── metadata.rs # File metadata structures +│ │ ├── move_record.rs # File move tracking +│ │ └── organization.rs # Organization plan structures +│ ├── settings/ +│ │ ├── mod.rs # Settings module exports +│ │ ├── config.rs # Configuration management +│ │ ├── prompt.rs # Interactive configuration prompts +│ │ └── tests.rs # Settings tests +│ ├── storage/ +│ │ ├── mod.rs # Storage module exports +│ │ ├── cache.rs # Caching system +│ │ └── undo_log.rs # Undo log management +│ ├── main.rs # Application entry point +│ └── lib.rs # Library exports +├── Cargo.toml # Dependencies and project metadata +├── Cargo.lock # Dependency lock file +├── config.example.toml # Configuration template +└── README.md # This file ``` +### Module Overview + +- **cli/** - Command-line interface and orchestration logic for organizing and undoing operations +- **files/** - File detection, batching, moving, and undo operations with concurrent processing +- **gemini/** - Google Gemini API integration with retry logic and intelligent prompt engineering +- **models/** - Core data structures for file metadata, move records, and organization plans +- **settings/** - Configuration management with interactive prompts and XDG directory support +- **storage/** - Persistent data layer for caching API responses and tracking undo history + ## Future Enhancements Based on community feedback, we're planning: diff --git a/src/files/batch.rs b/src/files/batch.rs index 232fd22..f111446 100644 --- a/src/files/batch.rs +++ b/src/files/batch.rs @@ -45,7 +45,6 @@ impl FileBatch { mod tests { use super::*; use std::fs::{self, File}; - use std::path::Path; #[test] fn test_file_batch_from_path() {